Gender News in Taiwan
2016.03.07
Legislator Wants Children in Chamber

【By Alison Hsiao】

Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Legislator Karen Yu on Thursday proposed that lawmakers be allowed to bring children under the age of three into the legislative chamber, triggering a mixed reaction from her colleagues, as well as government officials.

DPP Legislator Tuan Yi-kang tabled an extemporaneous motion yesterday in response to Yu’s proposal, demanding that the Legislative Yuan set up a daycare center for all parents working in the Legislative Yuan compound, including staff, journalists, lawmakers and their assistants.

Tuan said the Legislative Yuan should develop into a “friendly workplace,” and it should carry out childcare policies that the government has urged private businesses to follow based on the Act of Gender Equality in Employment, and set an example and reduce discrimination.

DPP Legislator Lin Shu-fen immediately voiced her support for Tuan’s proposal.

Tuan’s motion was a friendly response to Yu, a DPP legislator-at-large who made the amendment proposal that has since stirred debate both in the legislature and on the Internet.

The regulations governing the legislative general assembly chamber states that no one other than chamber staff and government officials and their assistants are allowed into the general assembly chamber. Yu has proposed amending the regulations to exempt lawmakers and officials “with children under three who need care and breastfeeding” from the rule.

Her draft amendment was supported in signature by more than a dozen lawmakers — including Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Ko Chih-en and New Power Party Legislator Kawlo Iyun Pacidal — and passed the first reading yesterday.

Yu made her first appearance in the Legislative Yuan on Feb. 1, when the first session of the new legislature convened, with her six-month-old child and said it was a pity that she could not bring her child into the chamber.

“This proposal is not for myself, as I have my family’s support in childcare, but what is on my mind is a presumption that the reason that there are so many double-income families who are not planning to have children is not only because of financial pressure, but also the conflicting nature between the working environment and childcare,” Yu said.

“Insofar as the Legislative Yuan is a highly symbolic institution, it should, in my opinion, hold an open attitude [to the measure],” Yu added.

Legislative Speaker Su Jia-chyuan said lawmakers’ proposals reflect society’s different perspectives and would be reviewed by the legislative committee.

“Taiwan is a democratic country and surely the issue could be put into discussion. And it would be up to the legislature for a final decision on whether it is okay” to bring children under three into the chamber, Su said, adding that he would remain neutral in the debate.

However, not everyone is supportive of the idea.

Premier Simon Chang said it would be “strange” to bring infants or toddlers to the chamber.

“Imagine you have small children crying or [people] breastfeeding when officials and lawmakers are in the middle of a question-and-answer session. It is strange,” he said.

“I think [Yu’s] idea is really about a childcare mechanism [in the Legislative Yuan], which can be done now, rather than bringing them into the general assembly chamber,” Chang added.
Minister of Justice Luo Ying-shay said “unpredictable situations” would happen if small children, who would “cry, make noise and run around,” are allowed in the chamber.

KMT Legislator Jason Hsu said it would not be appropriate for small children to be carried into the general assembly chamber, as “the congress hall is a serious place.”

Facebook community Impolite Netizen Group’s organizer yesterday apologized for his “indiscreet remark” made on Thursday upon hearing Yu’s proposal.

He had lambasted Yu for proposing a bill without “necessity” and for the possibility that people would have to watch small children crying in the chamber.

“After a long discussion with a coworker, I suddenly realized that I had made a big mistake by weighing in on the issue on the basis of taxpayers’ money, but this, if passed, would be a good example and have great impact on Taiwanese values in human rights, parents’ rights and women’s rights,” he said.

[Taipei Times, 2016-03-05]

  Gender News
in Taiwan
Capacity
Building
Women’s Rights in Taiwan Historical Reporting Cycles Current Reporting Cycle Videos  
  International Training Workshop on the Implementation of CEDAW The International Conference on the CEDAW Mechanism CEDAW Alternative Report Workshop Overview Ratification of International Human Rights Treaties Enforcement Act of CEDAW Historical Reporting Cycles Initial Country and NGO Reports